XEP-0301: Update STOX core reference to RFC 7247 - #1544
Conversation
b685171 to
5d28de9
Compare
|
Authorship note updated: this PR now adds Edward Tie / Tiedragon as a later author for this maintenance update, while keeping the original XEP-0301 authors first. The change is submitted for XEP Editor / Approving Body review together with the RFC 7247 reference update requested for XEP-0301 section 9.1. |
|
Thanks for this! We should consider making this change part of a larger effort: there's more updates that are likely required, as documented in #1520 One concern that we should be watchful of is that these entity definitions are re-used across all XEPs. It is unlikely that we want to keep one XEP on an older version of the specification, while we want another on a newer version, but still, we should check. Additionally, we ideally should make plausible that the updated RFC is still compatible with how they're used by the XEPs that currently depend on the older version/draft of the RFC. There may, after all, be material changes in the update of the RFC. |
Replace the stale STOX core draft reference with the published RFC 7247 entity and add Edward Tie as a later maintainer/author for this update. Co-authored-by: Edward Tie <4740735+edwtie@users.noreply.github.com>
5d28de9 to
553b883
Compare
|
Thanks, that makes sense. I checked the current
Both uses point at the same subject area covered by the final STOX core document: architecture, addresses, and error handling for SIP/XMPP interworking. The IETF Datatracker also marks If you prefer, I can narrow this PR to avoid the shared entity and instead update only the XEP-0301 text, but that would leave the SoX text pointing at the stale draft even though it uses the same SIP/XMPP address-mapping reference. |
|
I am not the boss of anything, but instead of narrowing the PR, I'd love to see it be used to replace more outdated RFC drafts. My uncertainty is around process. Is this an editorial change? Does this require approval from each XEP author that is affected? |
Summary
This updates XEP-0301's STOX core reference from the old draft-ietf-stox-core document to the published RFC 7247.
XEP-0301 section 9.1 uses
&stoxcore;when discussing guidance for XMPP/SIP address translation and conveyance. Peter pointed out that this should reference RFC 7247 instead of the old draft, so this PR updates the shared entity while keeping the existing entity usage intact.Authorship
This also adds Edward Tie / Tiedragon as a later author for this maintenance update. The original authors remain first in the author list; Edward is added after them for the current update work.
Compatibility note
The shared
&stoxcore;entity currently expands in XEP-0301 and the SoX ProtoXEP. Both uses refer to SIP/XMPP address translation or mapping, which is the same subject area covered by the final STOX core RFC.Notes
Validation
git diff --checkpassed.make .xep-0301.check.okcould not be run becausemakeis not installed on this Windows environment.